Global Economic Snapshot: December 2019

Uncertain Times & An Uneven Economic Landscape

The closing months of 2019 also brought to a close a decade of strong economic growth and robust labor markets for many of the world’s leading economies. However, the disruption caused by trade disputes and uncertainties have produced the first signals that this long period of sustained expansion may be coming to an end. Among the unresolved issues that continue to affect the global economy are:

  • The U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement, which was negotiated to replace NAFTA, has yet to be ratified by the legislature of all three nations. Author’s note: There may be a vote in the U.S. Congress in the coming weeks after a deal was struck by the Democratic leadership and the White House.
  • The ongoing trade war between the U.S. and China, the world’s two largest economies, continues and may continue into 2020.
  • Uncertainty over Brexit continued until the UK election on December 11, which very likely cleared the way for its departure from the European Union. Even with a firm Brexit date, a final trade agreement with the European Union has yet to be completed, and negotiations will be closely watched.

While job growth continued unabated in the labor markets of many key economies, the growth came at a slower pace than in 2018. Some of the most developed economies saw the period of sustained job growth halted and some unemployment rates began to climb. In addition to trade uncertainty, political upheaval and natural disasters also had negative effects on important economies in far-flung parts of the world.

Slowing Job Gains & Job Losses Materialize in the Labor Market

The U.S. labor market added 266,000 jobs in November and posted an unemployment rate of 3.5%. November’s results capped 110 months of continuous job growth, the longest period of sustained expansion in the nation’s history. The year began with an unemployment rate of 4% in January, which was the highest level all year. After hitting a half-century low of 3.5% in September, the unemployment rate rose slightly in October, only to come down to tie the fifty-year record level of 3.5%. While job openings steadily decreased to approximately 7 million, this level of openings was still larger than the number of unemployed Americans.

Additionally, the average monthly job growth improved to 180,000 per month in the 12 months leading up to November 2019. However, at the same time last year, the monthly average of jobs created was 223,000. So, while the job market was expanding, it did so at a slower pace than it did in 2018. The sectors that lost some jobs or grew at an anemic rate include manufacturing and retail. And, while manufacturing was disrupted by strikes and ongoing trade disputes, the diminishing jobs in retail were largely caused by the growth in online shopping, which has brought about a so-called “retail apocalypse” in the U.S. and elsewhere. 

Canada’s employment numbers were positive in much of the first half of the year and grew worse as the year wore on. After losing less than 2,000 positions in October, Canada’s economy shed 71,200 openings in a single month in November. While more than half of those (45,000) were lost in Quebec, other provinces also lost jobs and none had any notable job gains. Canada’s unemployment jumped 0.4% in November alone, reaching 5.9%. From a national perspective, the weak job outlook was not confined to manufacturing and retail as it was in the U.S.; although these were certainly weak in Canada, as well, it also extended to most major sectors of Canada’s economy.

In Europe, the economic landscape was mixed, with most major labor markets posting low unemployment rates that varied little from earlier in the year. In the UK, 58,000 jobs were lost in the quarter ending in September 2019. This was the second consecutive report with posted job losses, many of which analysts blamed on the uncertainty surrounding Brexit. However, the quarter ending in October showed a modest job increase of 24,000 positions, pushing employment to its highest level ever. Yet, even in the months when employment fell, the unemployment rate also dropped to a low 3.8%, which held steady in the August-October quarter; the UK unemployment rate has not been lower since 1974, well before the living memory of much of the UK workforce. And, while the results of the December national election opened the path for a departure from the European Union in early 2020, provisions of an eventual trade agreement between the UK and the EU remain to be seen.

Elsewhere in Europe, the Eurozone’s unemployment rate was 7.5% in October, the same as it was in June, but 0.3% lower than it was at the end of the first quarter. France posted an unemployment rate of 8.5%, falling from 8.7% in June, while Germany’s low unemployment rate of 3.1% in October was unchanged from its level in June.

In the Asia-Pacific region, unemployment rates rose in some leading labor markets, but only to relatively low levels. During the third quarter, China’s labor market reported an unemployment rate of 3.6%, a full percentage point higher than in the second quarter. Japan’s rate rose just 0.1% from June to October, landing at 2.4%. After experiencing considerable unrest, Hong Kong’s unemployment rate rose to 3.1% in October – from just 2.8% in June. And, in contrast with the rise in unemployment in other Asian powerhouses, South Korea’s unemployment rate fell an entire percentage point from June to October, ending at 3%. India’s labor market also had a drop in unemployment, falling 0.4% since June, to 7.5%.

The Oceania economies also posted mixed unemployment numbers from their respective labor markets. Australian unemployment was just 4.9% in February, an eight-year low, but it has been higher ever since, rising to 5.3% in October. New Zealand reported that its unemployment rate had fallen to 3.9% in the second quarter of this year – down from 4.3% at the end of 2018 – but then rose to 4.2% in the third quarter.

Wage Increases Outpace Inflation in Key Labor Markets

Annual wages have continued to grow faster than the rate of inflation in most leading economies. The U.S. annual wage increases stood at 3.1% in November, coupled with an inflation rate of less than 2% in the third quarter. In the UK labor market, nominal annual wages rose 3.5% in the quarter spanning August through October, which was also comfortably ahead of inflation. During the same period last year, nominal wages increased 3.3% annually, and the unemployment rate was 0.3% higher. Both the U.S. and UK posted higher annual wage gains earlier in the year, but the increases were not substantial relative to the tight labor markets in each country during much of the year. There is no clear consensus among economists as to why wages have not risen faster during the current sustained period of low unemployment.

In the Canadian labor market, annual wage gains fluctuated sharply during 2019; in May, they were just 2.1%, rising in July to 4.6%, but falling to 3.8% in September before landing back at 4.5% in November. This rising rate of wage increases came during the same month that Canada experienced its greatest job loss since the financial crisis. 

Australia instituted the highest minimum wage law in the world on July 1, 2019, but annual wage growth continued to be sluggish; year-over-year wage growth fell to just 2.2% in November, and Australian wage increases have been stagnant for some time. The last time the annual rate of increase was just 1% higher was in late 2012. And, without the robust minimum wage introduced earlier this year, wages could have potentially grown even more slowly. With unemployment above 5% for most of the year, analysts are not predicting significant wage gains until the labor market improves.

Political Unrest & Devastating Fires

Massive street demonstrations erupted in Hong Kong and in capitals around Latin America during the closing months of 2019, leading to significant economic costs. The capitals of Bolivia, Chile and Ecuador were roiled by anti-government protests. Specifically, Chile – which is considered by many to be an economic success story – had a 3.4% annual retraction in its economy in October, which was triggered by its civil unrest. As a result, the government agreed to a referendum to replace the constitution, and announced plans for a $5.5 billion economic stimulus package.

Similarly, protests in Hong Kong intensified after months of ongoing demonstrations and led to a shutdown of the city’s airport; traffic was also disrupted and major thoroughfares turned into sites of violent confrontations. The effects of the protests on Hong Kong’s economy have been devastating. In the retail sector alone, 7,000 firms are expected to close, and many of those that survive plan to lay off employees. Moreover, the government is forecasting a contraction of 1.3% for Hong Kong’s economy in 2019 – the first annual decline since the Great Recession in 2009.

Furthermore, powerful wildfires broke out in both California and Australia, causing extensive destruction and exacting economic costs in their respective economies. Workers in Sydney and other areas close to the fires struggled with smoke-filled air and, consequently, concerns for their personal health and safety. Meanwhile, in California, fires changed the landscapes of entire communities, and power was regularly cut off as a preventive measure to keep the fires from spreading.

The relentless threat of new wildfires and the intensity of the destruction of this year’s infernos have led some to conclude that the seemingly endless potential for prosperity in the nation’s largest state is over, and that this is the end of California as we know it. The fires in both places led to dislocations and business interruptions. While political unrest will inevitably fluctuate and appear in different locations around the world, destructive fires in both the western U.S. and Australia have become the new normal, and will likely continue to be a factor in the affected regions in the years to come.

PeopleScout Australia Jobs Report Analysis – November 2019

Australia’s economy gained 39,900 jobs in November. The unemployment rate fell to 5.2% in November as labour participation remained steady. The Bureau of Statistics reports that full-time employment increased by 4,200 and part-time employment rose by 35,700.

australia jobs report infographic

Numbers

+39,900: The Australian economy gained 39,900 jobs in November.

5.2%: Australian unemployment fell to 5.2%.

66.0%: Labour force participation was steady at 66.0%.

0: The Business Confidence Index fell to 0  in the latest NAB release.

Upside

The 39,900 jobs added in November were a welcome reversal of the job loss experienced in October. The number of unemployed Australians decreased by 16,800 to 708,100 people. Over the last year, full-time employment increased by 144,700, and part-time employment rose by 110,200. The job gains last month helped push the unemployment rate down one-tenth of a percentage point to 5.2%. While the participation rate remained stable at 66.0%, it is at a near record-high level. In another sign of progress, monthly hours worked in all jobs increased by 2.9 million hours in November.

In seasonally adjusted terms, the largest increases in employment were in Queensland (up 17,300) and Victoria (up 13,700). Some states also had jumps in their participation rates which indicates that more of their residents are being attracted into the workforce. The participation rate increased by 0.5% in Tasmania to 61.1%, 0.3% in Queensland to 66.2% (which is higher than the national rate) and in South Australia which grew by 0.2% to 62.9%.

Downside

Part-time job gains greatly outnumbered those in full-time employment. Only 4,200 full-time jobs were added compared to an increase of 35,700 in part-time work. The only job decrease was in New South Wales, the nation’s largest state by population which shed 2,800 positions. The seasonally adjusted participation rate there also decreased by 0.2%, falling to 65.3%.

The modest reversal in job growth has not inspired many economists to express optimism regarding Australia’s near-term economic outlook with some predicting a rise in unemployment next year. Capital Economics analyst Marcel Thieliant pointed to the fall in employment advertising as a sign that November’s job growth will likely be reversed: “The continued fall in job advertisements suggests that unemployment will climb further,” he predicted. “What’s more, households’ unemployment expectations are consistent with the unemployment rate rising to 5.5% by mid-2020.”

His sentiment was echoed by others including Indeed’s economist Callam Pickering who noted that the Australian labour market is showing “signs of fatigue” with an unemployment rate that has been continuously higher than the 4.9% level posted in early 2019.

Closing the Skills Gap:  Implications for Employers

While some economists are expressing concern over future job growth, many Australian workers appear to be concerned that they do not have the right skills to succeed in the jobs that will be available. A recent study by Centre for the New Workforce at Swinburne University of Technology, in partnership with YouGov, sought to reveal how Australian workers are preparing for the future of work which includes factors like digital transformation, artificial intelligence and automation. Their findings include:

  • 61% of Australian workers don’t think that their current skill set is suited for the next five years of work. This is a jump from 56% in just one year.
  • Key motivators for Australian workers include learning more and being stimulated by their work. In response to what inspires them most about their jobs 46% selected ‘the nature of the work itself’ and 34% chose ‘opportunity to learn and grow.’
  • For the main barriers to learning at work, 56% responded ‘not having dedicated time for learning’ and 39% cited ‘unsupportive working environment where learning is stigmatised.’
  • 51% of Australian workers spend less than one hour a week at work on learning in any form which includes 20% who state that they have no learning at all on their jobs.

The results of the study show that Australian workers are both concerned about their skill levels meeting future demand and not having the time or supportive environment to acquire the skills that will help them succeed. In order to retain their valuable workforce, employers should effectively communicate the learning opportunities that are currently available and develop these programs to include the skills that are anticipated to be needed in the future. It is also important to structure the work environment and scheduling to support continuous and effective learning. A successful learning programme can also be an important tool in attracting talent and can be featured as part of a sourcing effort and building an employer brand. Enterprises can effectively leverage their employee development and learning programmes to support retention and recruitment by partnering with a recruitment process outsourcer which can share its experience and expertise on how to maximize the impact of an enterprise’s investment in the learning and growth of its workforce.

PeopleScout UK Jobs Report Analysis — December 2019

The December Labour Market Report released by the Office for National Statistics, which includes the three month period covering August through October 2019, reported that 24,000 jobs were gained as the unemployment rate held at 3.8%.

UK jobs report infographic

Notable figures from the December report include:

  • The UK employment rate was estimated at 76.2%, 0.4 percentage points higher than a year earlier but with very little change over the previous quarter. Despite just reaching a new record high, the employment rate has had only small fluctuations over the last few quarters.
  • The UK unemployment rate was estimated at 3.8%, 0.3 percentage points lower than a year earlier but largely unchanged over the previous quarter.
  • Estimated annual growth in average weekly earnings for employees slowed to 3.2% for total pay (including bonuses) and 3.5% for regular pay.

Slight Job Gains after Consecutive Losses and Continued Low Unemployment

The 24,000 new jobs were welcome news after consecutive reports posting more than 100,000 job losses. The gains, while modest, beat analyst expectations, with one poll of economists predicting a median loss of 10,000 jobs. One particularly encouraging data point was an increase of 8,000 jobs in manufacturing, although a new study showed that a recent downturn in manufacturing output could have serious repercussions for the UK economy overall.  

The unemployment rate continues to be very low at 3.8%. It has not been lower since the final quarter of 1974, well before the living memory of much of the nation’s workforce. The UK economic inactivity rate was estimated at 20.8%, 0.2 percentage points lower than a year earlier but mostly unchanged over the previous quarter. The inactivity rate includes those in their prime working years who have not been seeking work within the last four weeks and/or unable to start work in the next two weeks.

The modest job gains and recent losses are viewed by some economists as part of a trend of diminished growth in employment compared to recent years. While uncertainty over Brexit may have played a role, employers have also faced challenges finding talent with the right skills for their open positions. As Tej Parikh, chief economist at the Institute of Directors, noted, “The UK’s jobs boom continues to be a big plus point for the economy, but it is slowly losing momentum. Businesses have shown a strong appetite to take on staff in recent years, and climbing employment levels have boosted household incomes, adding buoyancy to the economy. However, firms are now cutting back on new hires as it becomes harder to find the skills they need.”

Steady Decrease in Job Vacancies and Wage Growth Outpacing Inflation

The number of job vacancies has been dropping since early 2019. For the September to November 2019 period, there were an estimated 794,000 vacancies in the UK—20,000 fewer than for the previous quarter (June to August 2019) and 59,000 fewer than the previous year. (Job vacancies in the UK are reported over a three-month period beginning one month later than the other major labour market estimates.) While the fall in job vacancies has coincided with a drop in the unemployment rate, a continuing downward trend in open positions could have the adverse effect of discouraging additional workers to join the nation’s workforce next year.

The rate of annual pay growth reached 3.9% in the May-July 2019 period and was the highest nominal pay growth rate since 2008. In the August to October period, it dropped to 3.5%. While the annual pay increases are still well above the rate of inflation, there is no evidence future strong rate increases which have emerged in the past during times of very low unemployment.

Shifting Talent Pool

The period of the labour market report released today ended in October, more than a month before the national referendum, the results of which greatly increased the probability of Brexit on January 31, 2020. However, even while there was uncertainty over whether an exit from the European Union would ever come to pass, some striking migration figures began to emerge. The Office for National Statistics reported last month that net migration from the EU to the UK fell to its lowest level since 2003. In November, more than 140,000 EU citizens applied to live and work in the UK after Brexit adding to a backlog of more than 360,000 applications from those who are still waiting for a decision. At the same time, the level of non-EU migrants into the UK is reaching near record highs.

The volatile and fast-changing availability of talent from abroad adds to the already challenging conditions of extremely low unemployment faced by UK employers. Because of uncertain environment, partnering with experts in both the evolving talent market and employee acquisition such as a recruitment process outsourcer in the months to come may never have been more important as a factor to an enterprise’s success than in the year to come.

PeopleScout Canada Jobs Report Analysis — November 2019

Statistics Canada reported that the nation’s unemployment climbed to 5.9%. In November, 71,200 jobs were lost. Average weekly wages increased 4.5% over last year. Job levels were lost or were relatively unchanged in key sectors of the Canadian economy. The November job losses were the biggest the economy has had since the financial crisis more than ten years ago.

canada jobs report november 2019

The Numbers

71,200: The economy lost 71,200 jobs in November.

5.9%: The unemployment rate rose to 5.9%.

4.5%: Weekly wages increased 4.5% over the last year.

The Good

Statistics Canada reported that strong wage growth continued in November with average weekly wages increasing by 4.5% over twelve months. When viewed from an annual growth perspective, employment gains since November last year totaled 293,000 (+1.6%), with the increase largely accounted for by full-time work. Over the same period, total hours worked also grew by 0.2%.

While the job-loss numbers are significant, 20,000 of those jobs were due to the ending of temporary employment related to the recently completed federal elections. 

The Bad

Canada experienced its worst job loss in November since the Great Recession. Jobs were shed in both goods-producing industries and the service sector. 

In the goods-producing sector, fewer people worked in manufacturing which dropped by 28,000 positions and in natural resources (-6,500), with the bulk of the declines in each of these industries happened in Quebec. On an annual basis, Canada-wide employment in manufacturing was little changed, but it has declined in natural resources (-25,000 or -7.2%), mostly in Alberta and British Columbia. Job losses in the services-producing sector were led by those in public administration, where the number of workers fell by 25,000 in November.

Quebec was the hardest hit province in November where 45,000 fewer people were employed in November. This decline is primarily attributable to manufacturing and the accommodation and food services sector. Since more people looked for work in the province while jobs were dropping, the unemployment rate in the province increased by 0.6 percentage points to 5.6%.

Employment in Alberta fell by 18,000 in November, with declines happening in a number of sectors led by wholesale and retail trade. With more people seeking work, the unemployment rate in Alberta rose by 0.5 percentage points to 7.2% last month. Employment in British Columbia fell by 18,000 in November, with the losses spread across several industries. The unemployment rate rose to 5.0% in November from 4.7% in October.

Even in those provinces where the job markets did not have significant losses, unemployment rates rose. While employment in Ontario held steady in November, the unemployment rate increased by 0.3 percentage points to 5.6% as a result of more people looking for jobs. Employment in Saskatchewan was little changed, while the unemployment rate rose to 5.8% (+0.7 percentage points) as more people looked for work. There was also little employment change in Manitoba, and the unemployment rate edged up 0.3 percentage points to 5.6% in November.

The jobs report was seen by some analysts as shedding light on long-term weak spots in the Canadian economy, especially in manufacturing. Josh Nye, Senior Economist at RBC noted that there has been a steady decline in manufacturing jobs and that with ongoing trade uncertainty, there is no sign of recovery in the near future:

“That decline is pretty eye-catching. It’s one of the bigger stories. It’s one of the weaker industries if you’re tracking employment growth year-to-date, down an average 4,000 per month. Manufacturing has been weak globally this year. You’ve got rising trade tensions between the world’s two largest economies and slowing global growth that’s really been concentrated in the industrial sector.

Broadly speaking this is a sector that hasn’t generated much in the way of job growth for a number of years now so it’s hard to see that narrative changing in 2020.”

Canadian Career-Changers are Happier for Doing So. Could They Also be an Untapped Source of Talent?

The majority of Canadians who have switched careers say that they are happier because of their decision to do so according to a recent poll by Indeed Canada. Those who have been recently downsized or are otherwise concerned about their employment outlook or career future may choose to search for work outside their current field.

Almost nine out of 10 Canadians who have made a career change say they’re happier since switching career paths. Researchers polled 1,023 randomly selected full-time workers from a range of industries as well as education levels and found that 38% of them had made a complete career change at some point. Of the respondents, 35% said they were either currently thinking about switching careers or have thought about doing so. Of those respondents who have made a career change, 87% said they are happier since making the change.

Two important elements had to be a part of these Canadian’s successful career transformations.  First, the person making the career switch had to possess the skills to begin a new career or be ready and able to acquire them. Second, the employers who hired them had to have a broad view of their new employee’s potential to succeed, even if they have not had a matching job description in the past.

Rather than limit candidate sourcing to those in a given career category, employers can broaden their search to include those with different professional backgrounds that may be motivated to change careers and could be attracted to their job offerings. Identifying these individuals, especially for hard-to-fill positions in challenging markets needs the expertise and experience which is not always found in human resources departments that may already be stretched to the limit in their talent acquisition efforts. For this reason, it is a good idea to partner with a recruitment process outsourcing company with the knowledge and skills that can lead to the successful onboarding of those individuals from a wide range of career paths.

PeopleScout U.S. Jobs Report Analysis — November 2019

The Labor Department released its November jobs report which shows that U.S. employers added 266,000 jobs in November, beating analyst expectations. The unemployment rate fell to  3.5%, a 0.1% decrease from last month. The rate’s decrease was caused by strong job growth with little change to the labor participation rate. Year-over-year wage growth rose 0.1 percentage points to 3.1%. U.S. employers have added to payrolls for 110 straight months, extending the longest continuous jobs expansion on record.

jobs report infographic

The Numbers

266,000: The economy added 266,000 jobs in November.

3.5%: The unemployment rate fell to 3.5%.

3.1%:  Average hourly wages increased at a rate of 3.1% over the last year.

The Good

Reporting on the drop in unemployment and annual wage growth that is well ahead of the inflation may have been overshadowed by the robust (and unexpected) job growth last month. The monthly increase was the best since January’s 312,000 and well ahead of the November 2018 total of 196,000. November’s strong job expansion was fueled by gains in several key sectors. There were 45,000 health care jobs added with a jump in ambulatory health care services (up 34,000) and in hospitals (up 10,000). Over the last year, 414,000 health care jobs have been added to the U.S. economy.

Employment in professional and technical services rose by 31,000 in November and by 278,000 over the last year. Employment in leisure and hospitality continued to grow, adding 45,000 positions last month and a total of 219,000 jobs in just the last four months. Even the embattled retail sector showed modest job growth (up 2,000) which reflected rising employment in general merchandise stores (up 22,000) and in motor vehicle and parts dealers (up 8,000). 

The Bad

Some of the sector job gains are not as strong as they initially appear. The increase in retail jobs was offset by a loss of 18,000 positions in clothing and clothing accessories stores during the month that kicked off the traditional Christmas shopping season. While manufacturing gained 54,000 jobs last month following a decline of 43,000 in October, 41,000 of these were in auto manufacturing generated by thousands of General Motors workers who were returning to work after being on strike.

Despite the strong monthly report, job growth has averaged 180,000 per month this year compared with an average monthly gain of 223,000 in 2018. While the job market is expanding, it is doing so at a slower pace than last year. The most recent BLS report on U.S. job openings showed that they have fallen to their lowest level in a year and a half. While the number of jobs grew last month, the number of those employed part-time for economic reasons, which was reported as  4.3 million people, changed little in November. These individuals, who would have preferred full-time employment, were working part-time because their hours had been reduced or they were unable to find full-time jobs. Despite strong demand, employers were unable to significantly attract those in this category into the full-time workforce.

Plan for Continuing Tight Labor Markets

The November jobs report was perceived by many as demonstrating the continuing strength of the U.S. economy, despite ongoing concerns over the impact of tariffs and trade disputes. As the new year approaches, it is noteworthy that this is the first decade in which the U.S. has not experienced a major recession since the 19th century. Even as job openings fall, the number is still larger than the number of unemployed Americans. Fears of a recession being on the horizon are fading for some analysts.

As the economy grows, so does the demand for talent and businesses are planning for growth. For example, in the small business sector which has been a major driver of job growth, approximately 60% of the 654 employers surveyed in November said they planned to expand their headcount in 2020 and just 4% were planning cuts. 

While employers need to consider an array of directions the economy may take next year in their workforce planning, the optimism generated by the November jobs report indicates that expertise in both attracting and retaining talent will continue to be as crucial to the success of an enterprise in the coming years as it has been in the prosperous decade which is about to end.

Talking Talent: Recruiting and Retaining the Next-Gen Workforce with Kathryn Minshew of The Muse

In this episode of Talking Talent, we’re talking about the next generation workforce. For years, this conversation has been about millennials, but now the oldest millennials are in their late-30s and the youngest, their mid-20s. Now, most recent graduates are members of Generation Z.

How do employers attract and retain this new generation of workers? As they enter the workforce and start their careers, what sets them apart? And what are they looking for in an employer?

Joining us to talk about this is Kathryn Minshew, the CEO & Founder of The Muse, a career platform used by more than 75 million people to research companies and careers. In 2018, The Muse was named one of Fast Company’s 50 Most Innovative Companies in the World.

Kathryn is also the author of “The New Rules of Work,” a Wall Street Journal national bestseller. She has spoken at MIT and Harvard, contributed to the WSJ and HBR, and appeared on TODAY and CNN. She has also been named to SmartCEO’s Future50 Visionary CEOs and Inc.’s 35 Under 35. Kathryn worked on HPV vaccine introduction in Rwanda with the Clinton Health Access Initiative before founding The Muse and was previously at McKinsey & Company.

Additionally, Kathryn is the host of a new podcast from The Muse called “The New Rules of Work,” which interviews experts and leaders to explore the changing landscape of work. The New Rules of Work launched in November.

PeopleScout Australia Jobs Report Analysis – October 2019

Australia’s economy lost 19,000 jobs in October. The unemployment rate rose to 5.3% in October as labour participation slightly decreased. The Bureau of Statistics reports that full-time employment decreased by 10,300 and part-time employment fell by 8,700.

australia jobs report infographic

Numbers

-19,000: The Australian economy lost 19,000 jobs in October.

5.3%: The Australian unemployment rate rose to 5.3%.

66.0%: Labour force participation fell to 66.0%.

+2: The Business Confidence Index rose to +2 in the latest NAB release.

Upside

When viewed from a year-over-year basis, Australia’s full-time employment increased by 135,700 while part-time employment increased by 116,100. Western Australia had 6,300 job gains and Victoria added 2,900 positions. Western Australia also increased its participation rate by 0.2 percentage points to 68.3%, two percentage points higher than the national rate.

Both business confidence and conditions improved slightly during October. Despite the below-average ratings, NAB Group’s chief economist noted that there has been an uptick in both profitability and trading conditions. He also pointed to their survey which indicated that there would be ongoing employment demand of around 18,000 per month. However, that survey was completed before the release of the October report.

Downside

Australia had its sharpest job decrease in three years in October. The loss in both full-time and part-time employment suggests an overall softening of the job market. Nearly every state lost jobs including Queensland which lost 14,000, New South Wales with a decrease of 10,300 and South Australia which had a drop of 6,500 positions. With only Western Australia and Victoria posting notable job growth in October, the report can be viewed as essentially negative from a national perspective. The job losses were unexpected with some economists expecting a gain of 15,000 positions.

The number of those actively participating in the labour market also dropped, lowering the rate for a second month in a row. The underemployment rate which is a broader measure of joblessness increased by 0.2 percentage points to 8.5%. Seasonally adjusted monthly hours worked in all jobs decreased by 2.8 million hours (or 0.2%) in October.

Low Wage Growth:  A Challenge and an Opportunity for Employers

The weak jobs report came just one day after the ABS released its disappointing quarterly wage figures. The wage price index rose by just 0.5% in the quarter ending in September which brought annual growth to a tepid 2.2%. This is the slowest growth level in more than a year and fell short of both the Reserve Bank and federal Treasury expectations. 

One implication for Australian employers is that extended periods of low pay raises may lead valued employees to search for work elsewhere. 

While there are many factors that lead Australians to look for a new job and find a job offer attractive, at least one study found that salary was the most important:

“When asked what attracted them most to a workplace, the study revealed that salary came out on top, with 30% of Australians listing this at the most important factor when searching for a role.”

The slow wage growth being experienced throughout the country presents employers with both a dilemma and an opportunity. There is decreased competitive pressure to raise salaries and more good candidates may become available. To turn this situation to their advantage, some crucial questions arise. What is the correct wage level to best ensure employee retention? At the same time, what is the ideal pay package to attract talent that at least matches the offers from competitors and contributes to candidate acceptance? And how would a busy HR professional even begin to find the right answers to these questions?

There is useful information available, including data on wage ranges based on position descriptions, markets, education levels, years of experience and other factors. However, this data can be very expensive to purchase and time-consuming to review and interpret. In an economic environment in which many Australians may be motivated to search for their next job opportunity, an outside partner such as a recruitment process outsourcing company (RPO) can provide both the data and the analysis to that leads to solutions resulting in both keeping and attracting the right talent. Those enterprises that leverage both the knowledge and expertise brought by partnering with an RPO will have the tools to navigate a complex talent market and build a successful long-term talent strategy in an uncertain economic environment.

PeopleScout UK Jobs Report Analysis — November 2019

The November Labour Market Report released by the Office for National Statistics which includes the quarter covering July through September 2019 reported that 58,000 jobs were lost as the unemployment rate fell to 3.8%. Nominal wages showed an annual increase of 3.6%.

uk jobs report infographic

Notable figures from the September report include:

  • The UK employment rate was estimated at 76.0%; 0.5 percentage points higher than a year earlier but 0.1 percentage points lower than last quarter.
  • Job vacancies which were measured for the period covering August through October showed a decline of 18,000 openings compared to the quarter that ended in July.
  • Estimated annual growth in average weekly earnings for employees was 3.6% for both total pay (including bonuses) and regular pay (excluding bonuses). This is a decrease of .02 percentage points from last month’s report.

Job Losses Continued and the Unemployment Rate Fell

In the third quarter of 2019, the economy shed 58,000 jobs, following the decline of 56,000 positions reported last month. The loss was less severe than analysts had predicted—including a Reuters poll of economists which forecasted a median drop of 94,000 jobs. This was the largest drop since the three months ending in May 2015. The number of females in employment dropped by a notable 93,000. Among the reasons that this is a concerning figure is that women have been a driving force in the UK’s job gains in recent years. One important contributor to this decline are the continuing job losses in the retail sector.

Despite the loss of jobs, the unemployment rate fell to 3.8%. This is the lowest level since 1975, which is before the living memory of much of the nation’s workforce. Annual labour market numbers are still strong. There are 323,000 more people working in the UK than a year earlier. The job losses in the quarter were driven by a decrease of 164,000 part-time jobs which was offset by an impressive gain of 106,000 full-time positions.

In Northern Ireland, unemployment fell to a remarkable low of just 2.5%, a level more likely to be found in high-growth Asian nations than in a developed European economy.

Falling Vacancies, EU Nationals Leaving and Slowing Growth

The drop of 18,000 job vacancies from the previous quarter brought the number of decreased vacancies over the last year to 53,000. This is the fifth consecutive annual fall which suggests a trend of diminishing job openings.

Approximately 131,000 EU nationals left work in the UK over the quarter which is the largest decrease since the Office for National Statistics (ONS) began collecting records 21 years ago. This drop outnumbered the additional 125,000 UK nationals who entered employment.

Annual wage increases slowed to 3.6% which is still well ahead of the rate of inflation. However, if the demand for workers continues to fall, wage growth may continue to stagnate as well.

The nation’s economic growth rate is at its slowest in almost a decade, expanding by just 0.3% in the third quarter. This follows a contraction of 0.2% in the second quarter of 2019. Some economists are citing uncertainty over Brexit for the anemic economic figures:

“Tej Parikh, chief economist at the Institute of Directors, said that ‘a return to growth is welcome news, but narrowly avoiding a recession is nothing to celebrate.

The UK economy has been in stop-start mode all year, with growth punctuated by the various Brexit deadlines,’ he added.”

Everything is Possible

UK employers should look beyond the headlines and view this month’s report in context. Unemployment has not been lower in decades and 800,000 job vacancies are waiting to be filled. The result of next month’s election may or may not result in greater clarity concerning Brexit. It is the continuing lack of clarity over the nation’s economic future that should lead employers to actively seek out expertise in talent recruitment and retention. A partner such as a recruitment process outsourcing company can provide a range of solutions resulting in success in an uncertain environment. And as the novelist Dame Margaret Drabble has written, “when nothing is sure, everything is possible.”

PeopleScout Canada Jobs Report Analysis — October 2019

Canada’s unemployment remained at 5.5%. In October, 1,800 jobs were lost. Average weekly wages increased 4.2% over last year. There were strong job gains in the finance, insurance, real estate, rental and leasing sector and significant losses in manufacturing. The number of full-time jobs fell by 16,100, which was barely offset by a gain of 14,300 part-time jobs.

canada jobs report infographic

The Numbers

-1,800: The economy lost 1,800 jobs in October.

5.5%: The unemployment rate fell remained at 5.5%.

4.2%: Weekly wages increased 4.2% over the last year.

The Good

Statistics Canada reported that strong wage growth continued in October with average weekly wages growing by 4.2% over the last year. Average annual hourly wages grew by an even stronger 4.3%, the same as in September. On a year-over-year basis, employment in Canada increased by  443,000 or 2.4%, driven by gains in full-time work. During the same period, total hours worked were up 1.3%.

There were 17,800 job gains in the finance, insurance, real estate, rental and leasing sector, suggesting a healthy demand for talent in these important areas of the Canadian economy. The public sector also had a notable increase of 28,700 employees. Older Canadians also experienced an increase in their workforce numbers in October. Employment for people aged 55 and over rose by 31,000, with increases for both men (+17,000) and women (+15,000). The unemployment rate for this age group declined 0.2 percentage points to 4.7%. On an annual basis, employment for this group grew by 187,000 (+4.6%).

Employment increased in British Columbia (+15,300) and Newfoundland and Labrador (+2,700).

The Bad

After gaining of 54,000 jobs in September and 81,000 in August, the Canadian economy lost 1,800 jobs in October. Economists had predicted an increase of nearly 16,000 jobs. Major contributors to the job losses were construction and manufacturing, which fell by 21,300 and 23,100, respectively. Trade uncertainties have a negative impact on manufacturing and continued unease over trade has led some economists to temper their forecasts about Canada’s near-term economic growth.

While the Bank of Canada revised its 2019 Canadian growth projection up to 1.5% from 1.3%, it reduced its 2020 and 2021 forecasts to 1.7% from 1.9% and 1.8% from 2.0%, respectively. This was in part due to weaker foreign demand and trade uncertainty. BMO’s Chief Economist Doug Porter when interviewed stated “it’s pretty clear” the central bank is worried about global trade, adding it “gave a number of hints they would be prepared to move if things deteriorate at all in the months ahead.”

Although New Foundland and Labrador had slight job gains in October, the Maritime Provinces continue to experience unemployment rates that could more commonly be found during periods of recession. Newfoundland and Labrador unemployment stands at a staggering 11.1%, Prince Edward Island at 8.4%, Nova Scotia at 8.0% and New Brunswick at 8.3%.

The Unknown

Statistics Canada reported in October that over 1 million Canadians are holding down more than one job and are working more than 50 hours every week. Canadians working multiple jobs has nearly doubled since 1978, growing quickly in the 1980s, and then rising to 5.7% of all Canadian workers in 2018.

The report found that women, part-time workers and Canadians in their 20s are the most likely to have multiple jobs. It also reported that Canadians who hold more than one job typically work in sectors with strong female participation such as health care and social assistance, and educational services.

A recent Bank of Canada survey found that one-third of Canadians chose to engage in “informal work,” which includes driving for a ride-sharing service, housecleaning and babysitting, due to their need for additional income.

While it is clear that a significant number of Canadians are working long hours and at more than one job, what is less clear is the number of these workers who have searched for new positions with more competitive wages. Finding new employment which provides better income could eliminate the need for informal work and holding more than one job.

The lack of free-time that many of these workers experience may inhibit their ability to conduct a successful job search. The challenge for Canadian employers looking for talent is to attract those who are working multiple jobs that have the skills, or the ability to be trained, and whose income needs can be met by their enterprise’s open positions.

While multiple-job holders may be motivated to pursue new opportunities once they become aware of them, finding the right candidates among them may be a challenge. To reach this group of potentially untapped talent, employers should leverage the experience and expertise of a recruitment process outsourcing company. The result could be the onboarding of hard-working, and grateful, new employees.

Talking Talent: Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Talent

In this special episode of Talking Talent, we discuss artificial intelligence and the impact it will have on recruiting.

Instead of an interview, this episode is a recording of a presentation by Dr. Rand Hindi from our London “Resourcing 2025” event. At that event, PeopleScout launched the next generation of RPO featuring a future-focused approach to service RPO customers across Europe. There, Dr. Hindi described recent developments in artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning and implications those will have on the talent landscape of the future.

Dr. Hindi is an entrepreneur and data scientist. He is the founder and CEO of Snips, building the first AI assistant that protects privacy. Rand started coding at the age of 10, founded a Social Network at 14 and a web agency at 15 before getting into Machine Learning at 18 and doing a PhD in Bioinformatics at 21. He has been elected as a TR35 by the MIT Technology Review, as a “30 under 30” by Forbes, as a Rising Star by Founders Forum, and is a member of the French Digital Council. He holds a BSc in Computer Science and a PhD in Bioinformatics from University College London (UCL), as well as two graduate degrees from Singularity University in Silicon Valley and THNK in Amsterdam.

In the presentation, Dr. Hindi shares his conclusion that for the best results, AI and humans will need to work together to make recruitment decisions. AI provides speed, accuracy and algorithms while humans contribute empathy, emotional intelligence and the ability to solve logical paradoxes. Dr. Hindi explains the differences between the types of intelligence that can be programmed into computers, and the more complex emotional intelligence that cannot be replicated by machines. He also shares the history of artificial intelligence, and what he expects the technology to be capable of in the future.